1. Greater influence over spatial planning
The introduction of Spatial Development Strategies in England reflects a growing role for regional spatial planning and provides a potential opportunity to strengthen the link between spatial and energy planning. While the extent to which energy will feature in these strategies remains to be seen, they could provide a mechanism for strategic authorities to have greater influence over planning policy for renewable energy development across their regions. This could include ensuring that Spatial Development Strategies take account of future energy needs and infrastructure requirements.
However, planning is a devolved matter, as such it will be important to consider the extent to which the different planning regime in Scotland creates challenges for alignment. In England there may also be scope for a more direct decision-making role, with the UK government having recently consulted on proposals to give mayors decision-making powers over certain renewable energy planning applications.
2. A potential role for regional energy planning?
One possible mechanism to achieve the Energy Secretary’s aim for greater energy system co-ordination could be regional energy plans. These would set out future energy ambitions tailored to the needs of an area, which could then help combined authorities to understand and advocate for their priorities when engaging with the Regional Energy Strategic Plan (RESP) process.
An important question is what value an additional ‘energy plan’ could provide here or how much of this is about developing methods to consolidate energy needs from existing local and regional plans into approaches such as the Spatial Development Strategies. Consideration will also need to be given to how regional priorities are fed into electricity distribution network operators' (DNOs) plans.
3. Coordination and representation at RESP level
There may be potential opportunities for strategic authorities to have greater representation and influence within existing regional energy decision-making structures. This could include potentially approving or appointing regional RESP chairs or establishing more formal governance arrangements with DNOs.
The aim of such measures would be to ensure regional priorities are clearly represented in decisions about the future energy system. However, we know that the geographies of devolution do not currently align with the RESP boundaries, which could become a significant barrier to effective coordination and action.
4. Shaping electricity network connections and investment
As raised by the Prime Minister, timely grid connections are becoming a blocker to investment and business growth. One possible solution could be giving strategic authorities a greater role in influencing how connection capacity is prioritised. This could help balance the needs of new housing, industrial development and other large electricity users, supporting regional priorities for economic growth.
Alongside this, there may be opportunities for greater influence over where and when investment in new electricity network infrastructure takes place. This could include influencing network investment plans and contributing to decisions on strategic investment in the distribution grid and investment uncertainty mechanisms. There may also be scope to influence the development of local flexibility markets.
5. Supporting local electrification and funding regional energy ambitions
Strategic authorities could play an increasingly important role in accelerating the uptake of low-carbon technologies such as heat pumps and electric vehicles, supporting the delivery of their wider regional energy ambitions. Building on the Integrated Settlements approach, the government has signalled its intention to devolve elements of the Warm Homes Plan and GB Energy's Local Power Plan. This creates an opportunity for strategic authorities to take a more coordinated approach to local infrastructure delivery, tailoring support to regional priorities.
This role could be developed further, including by shaping or directing DNO support for low-carbon technology rollout. Alongside this, a key question remains around how strategic authorities could access and coordinate the funding needed to deliver their ambitions. This could include through relationships with the National Wealth Fund, Great British Energy and other funding mechanisms such as devolved innovation funding.
Next steps
The questions raised here illustrate the scale of the challenge when it comes to balancing national, regional and local responsibilities for shaping energy decisions. Not every power will be suitable for devolution, and new responsibilities will need to work alongside existing regulatory frameworks as well as electricity networks and other key organisations.
Getting energy into the devolution conversation as it develops will be essential. To deliver ‘growth in every postcode’, regions will need the powers to shape their ambitions and an energy system that is able to support them.
Our research paper will be published early in the new year. If you have specific evidence, policy proposals or practical experience that could inform our recommendations, please get in touch.